Bow and Sword

by

Michael Carter


Joseph Boulogne, Chevalier de Saint-Georges (ca. 1739-1799)

African-American composers have made a significant impact upon our nation's musical heritage in the fields of ragtime, swing, jazz, blues, and of course rap, but few of us pause to consider their contributions to the Western classical music genre. In fact, some of us are totally ignorant of it. There is a significant body of high quality classical music by African-American composers. Some of these compositions were written by jazz artists like Duke Ellington, whose suite entitled The River, falls into a category that the music industry refers to as "crossover". But the name that first comes to mind when one thinks of a purely classical African-American composer is that of William Levi Dawson (1899-1990), the former head of the Department of Music at Tuskegee Institute (now Tuskegee University) in Alabama. Conservatory-trained and a professional trombonist, Dawson was the first African-American to have a major work -- his Negro Folk Symphony -- professionally recorded. That privilege went to none other than the fabled Leopold Stokowski, former conductor of The Philadelphia Orchestra, and his American Symphony Orchestra.

Dawson -- along with José White, William Grant Still, George Theophilus Walker, and many others -- forms part of a long line of African-American composers and performers whose classical music heritage and artistic ancestors included an African-English composer and conductor named Samuel Coleridge-Taylor. In the second decade of the 20th century, he was the first man of African heritage to conduct the New York Philharmonic and his ability was described by those who played under him as being on a par with the finest European conductors of the day. Performers of African heritage could also be found in Europe in the early 19th century. Beethoven composed his well-known "Kreutzer" sonata for a violinist of African-English heritage by the name of Augustus Bridgetower.

Over twenty-five years ago, CBS Records issued a short-lived series of LP recordings devoted to the music of African-American and African-European composers who were active from the 18th through the 20th centuries. The recordings were conducted by this country's best-known African-American maestro, Paul Freeman. Unfortunately, since the advent of the compact disc and the subsequent purchase of the recording division of CBS by Sony, those rare and now coveted LP releases have been deleted from the firm's catalog and as of this writing, there are no plans afoot to re-release the material on compact disc.

Among the recordings was an album of music by one Joseph Boulogne, called Chevalier de Saint-Georges (ca. 1739-1799). But after a quarter-century of unmerited neglect by the world's major producers of classical music recordings, Saint-Georges' music is again reaching the public due to the efforts of Tennessee-based Naxos USA. A series of compact discs devoted to all of Saint-Georges' violin concertos is in preparation. They are performed by renowned Japanese violinist Takako Nishizaki and the world famous Cologne Chamber Orchestra, conducted by Helmut Müller-Bruhl. The first disc -- released in 2002 as Naxos 8.555040 -- contains two of Saint-Georges' concertos from his Opus 2 set and a single concerto that was published as Opus 8.

The multi-year project is a collaborative effort by Naxos with the New Zealand music-publishing firm, Artaria Editions, Ltd. Artaria specializes in researching, editing, and engraving rare and neglected classical music repertoire from the 18th and early 19th centuries. Artaria and its corporate partner, Naxos, are currently engaged in an encyclopedic recording project that -- when complete -- will provide an aural documentary of the development of the symphony and the concerto in 18th century Europe.

But what makes Saint-Georges so special that he has attracted the attention of a music publishing firm more than half a world away? Dr. Allan Badley, Managing Director of Artaria, and an internationally recognized expert on European music of the mid to late 18th century explains: "Joseph Boulogne, called Chevalier de Saint-Georges, was widely regarded as the most accomplished man of his age. Not only was he among the most important musicians in Paris during the pre-Revolutionary period," Badley, who also edited the music for the recording sessions, continued: "But Saint-Georges was also a superb, all-round athlete and man of arms. Among connoisseurs of the art of fencing, Saint-Georges was considered the finest swordsman in Europe, possessed of extraordinary speed, flexibility and grace, qualities that he also exhibited in abundance as a violinist."

"In an age when slavery was endemic and slaves were regarded as ‘moveable objects’, beasts of burden to be starved, beaten, tortured and killed at will, Saint-Georges, was without doubt one of its most celebrated of men," Badley added. According to Badley, Saint-Georges' origins -- in many older published accounts -- are incorrect in detail, but essentially accurate in substance. "Recent research has established that his father was one George de Bologne Saint-George, a former Gentleman of the King’s Bedchamber and an important planter at Basse-Terre, Guadaloupe. Nothing is known of Saint-Georges' mother beyond the fact that she was a beautiful young slave of Senegalese origin who was given the name Nanon. She may have been one of the Boulogne family's household slaves." When Saint-Georges was young, his family relocated to Saint Domingue (now Haiti), and at the age of ten, they -- along with Nanon -- returned to France. There, the child's lifestyle underwent a phenomenal change. In addition to becoming involved in a host of activities -- including riding, dancing, swimming, and skating -- Saint-Georges became a master swordsman; in his prime, he was considered the finest in Europe. His famous contemporary, Henry Angelo, claimed that Saint-Georges "…combined in his person his mother’s grace and good looks and his father’s vigour (sic) and assurance."

When Saint-Georges turned thirteen, his father, perhaps intending him for a military career, boarded him with the Master of Arms, La Boëssière. La Boëssière’s son, also a famous swordsman, trained from boyhood alongside Saint-Georges. In his foreword to the second edition of his father’s La Traité de l’Art des Armes, the younger La Boëssière writes: "From the age of eight when my father first put the foil in my hand I had the inestimable advantage of being trained under his instruction and brought up with M. de Saint-Georges, who was my friend and companion in arms right up to his death. "No one else under instruction showed as much gracefulness and discipline. His stance was superb and with his hand held high he could always exploit the faults of his opponent. His left foot was firm and never wandered, and his right leg stayed absolutely straight. This combination gave him the poise he needed to recover his position and go back on to the attack with the speed of lightning…He made good use of the gracefulness and talent that nature had bestowed on him, and those watching were amazed. When he was fencing with friends he was full of consideration. But woe betide anyone who tried to take advantage! If he noticed this he took his revenge with interest."

Between 1758 and 1768, the young Saint-Georges mastered musical composition and his instrument as quickly and as securely as he did fencing. He studied violin with the famous Jean-Marie Leclair and composition with François-Joseph Gossec. The latter eventually appointed Saint-Georges as first violin in the orchestra of the prestigious Concerts des Amateurs, one of the foremost musical organizations in Paris. When Saint-Georges appeared in 1772 as soloist in his own violin concertos, his reputation was even further enhanced. The following year, Saint-Georges replaced Gossec as the director of the concert series that the latter founded.

The music composed by Saint-Georges is similar to that of Mozart in its character: bright, witty, charming, elegant, wholly accessible, and eminently listenable. Not a note is wasted, nor a phrase superfluous. It is filled with virtuosity, but there are also many opportunities for the violin to sing. "As a composer, Saint-Georges was noted for his ability to pen stimulating and exquisite melodies, one after another. His melodic gifts are most apparent in the slow movements which are without question among the most beautiful of any composer of the period. The virtuosic first movements radiate a kind of leisurely grace through Saint-George's elegant melodic ideas," remarked Badley.

But circumstances in France would soon take a dramatic and irrevocable turn, and Saint-Georges would find himself wielding an officer's sword and not a violinist's bow. The 1780s brought political turmoil and eventually revolution to France, and the now ennobled Chevalier de Saint-George took the side of the newly-formed Republic, assembling a military force in northern France. In 1791, he completely abandoned his once-beloved music to assume command of the National Guard in Lille, but after being wrongly accused of misappropriating money intended for his unit, Saint-Georges was stripped of his command and imprisoned. After his release, Saint-George left for Saint Domingue upon hearing of a slave revolt in his homeland. Returning to Paris in 1797, he attempted in vain to recover his once-prominent position in musical society, but failed and died a pauper after giving up his wealth and life to the Revolution.

At his death, there was no knowledge of any family. His father had a legitimate daughter, but the search for her was in vain. Perhaps she had emigrated, or perhaps she had died. There was never any record of her having any contact with her half-brother. This man who was once so sought after, ended his life with nothing and no one. There were certainly greater composers during the late 18th century, but none of them -- not even the great Mozart -- possessed anywhere near the remarkable range of talents, exotic persona, and fascinating personality of Joseph Boulogne, Chevalier de Saint-Georges. He was, by every measure, a man.